Battlefield diary
…..or more accurately, battlefield tour diary. The family and I have just returned from a long weekend family trip to Gettysburg and I thought that I would share my experience with anyone who is interested.
April 16th, 2011: Unlike the first three days of July in Gettysburg in 1863, it was in the forties, very windy and raw, with a steady rain heavy at times. The weather didn’t matter because we were at the site of one of the most famous battles of the Civil War, the history of the location helped to overcome the less than perfect weather conditions.
Our first stop on Saturday was Cemetery Hill, there were statues and cannons facing the fighting field and we were all in awe of the fact that we were standing on the ground where a great battle once took place. We could see Culp’s Hill–the Union’s right flank– in the distance; we were all surprised at how “intact” and unchanged the area of the battle was, it was if it was frozen in time.
From Cemetery Hill we made our way over to the “Soldiers Cemetery” where the Union soldiers who died at Gettysburg are buried–and the site where President Lincoln gave his most famous speech. The graves of the soldiers form a semi-circle pattern and they are buried by state regardless of the rank they held when they were felled. Seeing so many graves in one location–and so many graves of unknowns who were so horribly disfigured they couldn’t be identified–really drove home the enormity of this three day battle.
When we left the cemetery we headed to the Gettysburg National Military Park Museum and Visitors Center. This is a must see for anyone who decides to take this trip. The museum is full of Civil War relics–from weapons to uniforms to just about anything else you can think of–including the desk and bed that General Lee carried with him to Gettysburg and the stretcher that carried General Jackson off of the battlefield at Chancellorsville.
Now it was time for a little lunch, so we decided to eat at General Pickett’s All You Can Eat Buffet–which was fittingly located at the edge of Emmitsburg Road. After lunch we began what I thought was the best part of our trip–the auto tour of the battlefield. The auto tour is basically a circuitous road around the battlefield where you can see all of th major points of this battle.
We started out on Confederates Way–monuments mark the exact locations of Confederate divisions. We are basically on the Confederate line at this point and it is remarkable to see how long the line of battle was. From here we travel to Little Round Top.
Standing on Little Round Top I can envision it:
Col. Chamberlain is told that his division–the 20th Maine–is the end of the line. He must hold his position until the last. He cannot let his line be turned and he cannot retreat and he will not be reenforced. The 20th Maine holds off several advances from the Confederates but they are all but out of ammunition when they see the Confederates mounting yet one more attack.
Knowing that there are only two possible outcomes–victory or death–Col. Chamberlain orders a daring bayonet charge on the Confederates and against all odds manages to repel the last Confederate advance on Little Round Top.
With the attacks on the Unions right and left flanks both ending in failure General Lee–who until this point has never lost a battle–has but one option left, attack the Union center. And that is exactly where the auto tour took us next.
The family and I are now standing on Cemetery Ridge, right next to THE copse of trees that General Lee orders the attack to focus on. We are looking over the vast field below, with Emmitsburg Road about halfway between where we are standing and the woods in the distance.
Again, in my mind I can see this all play out:
It has gone down in history as Pickett’s charge, but in reality Pickett was only one of three generals who participated in this charge. As I look over the fields which continue from left to right as far as the eye can see, I can see it. Out of the woods comes a battle line one mile long making its way across the field, attempting to march on the position I am now standing on one mile away.
Against all odds the Confederates manage to continue advancing in spite of the heavy artillery fire. But then they hit Emmitsburg Road-with its fence on both sides–and are shot dead as they try to advance beyond this obstacle. The bodies pile up at the fence, but still the Confederates do not stop.
Amazingly and against all odds the Confederates manage to reach and break the Union line, but General Stuart’s cavalry–which was supposed to meet Pickett’s charge from the rear and split the Union army in two–never reaches the battlefield because he is intercepted by the soon to be infamous General Custer. Union soldiers manage to reverse the Confederate attack–which suffered over 50% losses. The Confederate attack had failed, and on July 4th 1863, General Lee retreated from the battlefield. Looking down from Cemetery Ridge and seeing how far the Confederate soldiers advanced while facing withering artillery fire is simply amazing, but they simply pushed ahead in spite of the long odds.
Looking over Cemetery Ridge and seeing how enormous this attack must have been is hard to describe–standing at the copse of trees, and at Little Round Top looking at the monuments that mark the “Devils Den” and the “Slaughter Pit” really drive home the enormity of the struggle that occurred here.
Gettysburg has done a great job at upkeep in regards to the battlefield. There are modern amenities in the town but the battlefield remains unchanged. I have always wanted to visit the Civil War battlefields in the south and now I want to visit them even more. Anyone who is a Civil War buff should make the trip to Gettysburg–you will not be disappointed.
The weather did not make it easy to take pictures, but here are the pictures that we were able to get on our trip, enjoy:

I was at the battlefield in 2004 and let me tell you Steve it is an experience that I will always treasure and never forget. When I looked across the open field where Pickett’s charge took place the first thought that came to mind was “My God Lee, what were you thinking?” In order to truly understand the battle and how difficult it was for both sides, you really need to visit it.
LikeLike
It is simply amazing to see! Pickett almost succeeded and Lee almost pulled it off, if it wasn’t for a chance meeting between Stuart and Custer Gettysburg may have fallen to the Confederates and Lincoln may have had to negotiate with the south.
LikeLike
I went there 15 years ago, or so. I had the same impression about Pickett’s charge. It was suicidal to be sure. Wasn’t it also the ineffective Confederate artillery barrage to helped the Union as well? Bad fuses, if I remember correctly.
LikeLike
You are right about the artillery barrage, but I believe they misjudged the distance and fired behind the Union line rendering it ineffective. It really is amazing to look out over the feild and think about how massive Pickett’s charge was, and to think that he actually made it to the Union line under those conditions is amazing.
LikeLike
The pics are great Steve… Weather be damned, you had a great view…
LikeLike
It was great in spite of the rain. Although I have to admit I felt a little wimpy standing on Little Round Top with an umbrella thinking about what happened there almost 150 years ago. 🙂
LikeLike
Awesome! Thanks for posting. I did a Unit Study with my son on the Civil War for school this year and then I’ve done a lot of reading myself. I can’t wait to visit Gettysburg, so I appreciate your post.
Did you see that new movie coming out by Robert Redford on the Civil War? I was excited to see it because I had learned about John Wilkes Booth and his conspirators and how Mary Surratt was the first woman in the U.S. to be hanged. But when I read the reviews even the entertainment guys said that Redford was trying to prove a political point about 9/11, rather than just telling the historical story. So we’ll have to see.
LikeLike
You won’t be disappointed when you get there, it is truly awe-inspiring to any history buff. I can’t wait to see some of the other battlefields–Anietam and Chancellorsville are on my list.
That movie is one that I will have to see, although I wondered if there would be a political point to it. There is also a movie coming out based on Doris Kearns Goodwin’s book “Team of Rivals” that I am looking forward to.
LikeLike
Thanks so much for sharing your trip, Steve. I never took the time to do what you are doing and now it’s to late for me. I hope your story encourages people not to make the mistake I made.
LikeLike
You are welcome, I have wanted to visit this site, and other Civil War sites as well, for a long time and I am glad that I finally made the trip. My dream vacation is to visit the beaches of Normandy, but I doubt that I will ever have that chance.
LikeLike
Thanks for going down memory lane. I visited there last year and was one of the most moving experiences for me. I have been to other war sites, but after going to the visitors center, it really became alive. It is important to remember all that gave so much for us.
One can buy CD’s at the center for the Auto Tour and can be played describing via personal accounts what was going on at those locations.
LikeLike
You’re welcome, it really is moving to stand on that site and think back to those days. You can actually picture what happened. I hope someday to visit other sites as well–Anietam and Chancellorsville first and foremost on that list. I know that the bus tours had audio that played as you toured the battlefield, but I did not know that I could have bought a CD to listen to during the auto tour–that would have been pretty cool.
LikeLike
Thank you for sharing Steve. It’s been years since I was there, and it was nice to see the pictures. I’m glad you had a nice time.
LikeLike
You are welcome. We did have a great time, and I want to go back sometime when I have a little more time.
LikeLike
Great stuff Steve, sounds like you had an awesome and humbling experience. You descriptions are fantastic as well, good stuff. =)
LikeLike
Thank you! It was humbling to say the least, we had a great time and I only wish that I had a couple of more days to look around. My dream trip is to visit the beaches of Normandy, I can’t even begin to image how humbling and emotional it would be to actually stand on the beaches where the liberation of a continent began.
LikeLike
I was a reenactor for the 135th Gettysburg Reenactment and we did actual size Picketts Charge. It was about 6ooo Union and 13ooo Confederate participants, talk about awe-inspiring. The Battlefield itself is something everyone should experience, there are stories of heroism and sacrifice at every turn. It is always good to see others appreciate it’s significance. Great job on the pictures.
LikeLike
That must have been something to see! There are going to be reencatments this year on the first three days in July and I would love to check them out. There certainly were acts of heroism and sacrifice on both sides of the battlefield.
LikeLike
I just remember when I went in 7th grade they told us the Confederates were hiding in a corn field and ate a steady diet of corn and tomatoes which gave them all diarrhea meaning they were very dehydrated when fighting time came.
LikeLike
I hadn’t heard that but I wouldn’t be surprised if that was the case.
LikeLike
I watched the 1993 movie Gettysburg last night and it really seems like RE Lee screwed up big time yet he is heralded as this amazing general when it looks like he caused the South to lose the war. Why is that?
LikeLike
I do believe that General Lee is one of the greatest battlefield generals in history. He had a long and illustrious career before the Civil War and was serving in the Lincoln andministration before the war. He was thought of so highly that Lincoln offered him command of the northern army and I believe if he had accepted it the war would have been much shorter. While Gettysburg was not his finest moment, up until that point he had not lost a battle in the war; despite being constantly outnumbered and in many cases out supplied he managed to stay one step ahead of the federals for three years.
While he lost at Gettysburg, he did have a plan in place that could have–and almost did–win that battle. There are a few “ifs” involved but Chamberlain’s bayonet charge was an act of desperation and if it had failed the federal line would have been flanked, leading to disaster for the federals. Chamberlain’s manuvering at LRT was brilliant. that cannot be taken away, but I am still amazed he managed to hold off the confederates.
But the biggest “if” was strangly missing from the movie (probably for time constraints): You remember the scene when Lee confronts Stuart and tells him not to let him down again? Well, he did. Part of Pickett’s charge was supposed to include Stuart manuvering behind the federals so that when the south took the hill Stuart would have been there from behind and would have split the federals in half ensuring victory. But Stuart never made it because of a chance encounter with General Custer. Pickett actually broke through the federal line before being driven back, if Stuart had made it the federals would have lost.
So while Gettysburg failed I don’t think Lee can be judged solely on this battle. The plan could have worked and if it did he would have been able to march on Washington.
LikeLike