GITMO Detainees to be Moved to Montana?
Is this what the proponents of closing GITMO had in mind when they learned that the president was going to fulfill a campaign promise to close GITMO? Moving the detainees to a Montana jail?
I thought that the idea behind closing GITMO was that these prisoners were not really enemy combatants and that we were holding them illegally and abusing them. Why if we are illegally holding them should we then bring them to this country and continue to illegally hold them?
If they are being held illegally it is time to release them, if we have a legitimate reason to hold them than we have been lied to all of these years by the left for political gain. The truth is that these are dangerous people who need to be detained and the president knows this but in an effort to appease the far left he signed the order to close GITMO without considering what to do with the prisoners.
Now he is left with no place to put these enemy combatants, their own countries do not want them back. So it looks like he may ship them to Montana and keep them detained there. The question I would ask the left is, what is the difference where these prisoners are being held? The fact remains that many of them cannot be released into society and there never was a chance that they would be.
GITMO was used as a political tool and a wedge issue in the 2008 election, but nobody really believed that these people deserved to, or could, be freed did they? If, as the president claimed during the campaign, these people were being held illegally without being tried than the proper thing to do would be to try them in a court of law or let them go. But so far the administration has continued the Bush policies, perhaps President Bush was right all along. Why else would the current president continue the Bush policy on the GITMO detainees?
The fact that these people are still going to be held, even if it is in a different location, tells us all that we need to know about them. The fact remains that issuing the order to close GITMO was nothing but a political stunt.
These people should be kept in GITMO and never be allowed to set foot in the United States, if they go to trial let them face trial in GITMO. If they are going to be held indefinitely, let them be held in GITMO. If, as it appears, the president is just going to follow the Bush policy on GITMO detainees, let them stay in GITMO. Why bring them here is nothing is going to change?
This was a publicity stunt from day one, nothing will change but the location.
Forgive me, but how could I end a post about moving to Montana without including some lyrics from the Frank Zappa song, Montana?
With a
Pair of heavy-duty
Zircon-encrusted
tweezers in my hand
Every other wrangler would say
I was mighty grand
By myself I wouldn’t
Have no boss,
But I’d be raisin’ my lonely
Dental Floss
Raisin’ my lonely
Dental Floss
Raisin’ my lonely
Dental Floss
Well I might
Ride along the border
With my tweezers gleamin’
In the moon-lighty night
And then I’d
Get a cuppa cawfee
N’ give my foot a push . . .
Just me ‘n the pygmy pony
Over the Dennil Floss Bush
N’ then I might just
Jump back on
An’ ride
Like a cowboy
Into the dawn to Montana
Movin’ to Montana soon
(Yippy-Ty-O-Ty-Ay)













“I thought that the idea behind closing GITMO was that these prisoners were not really enemy combatants and that we were holding them illegally and abusing them.”
You were wrong, simple as that. I’m sure you are used to be wrong though.
LikeLike
Please elaborate.
LikeLike
I don’t know about you, I’m not sure that I would like America hating prisoners who were not given the “country club” experience housed in the country. My thought is that we just open the gates of Gitmo and tell them to find their own way home.
LikeLike
Send them back where they came from would be my preference. Whatever happens to them there is their problem.
LikeLike
That would be my preference as well except the countries from where the came don’t want them back.
LikeLike
That is why I am still not convinced that GITMO is going to close. I don’t think most Americans want these people brought here and they can’t go home.
LikeLike
You make some good points Mr. Pinkeyes, I do however that a somewhat different position. If they must be moved then Montana would be a great place. If they should manage to escape from GITMO and slip across the fence into Cuba they would be received publicly as heros then locked away in the dungeons of the presidental palace. On the other hand should they escape from their hold facility in Montana, the cowboys their have a history of a tall tree and a short rope. Your poem was entertaining. I’ve been very much under the weather and able to do little by way of posting or comment hope to find out what the problem is this upcoming week. Thanks for your visits to my site.
LikeLike
I didn’t look at it from that angle. Maybe Montana is a good plce for them after all.
LikeLike
Uh…. he really seems to be dragging this out, doesn’t he? If he insists on closing GITMO I think he should take Murtha up on his offer. Business will sure pick up at Murtha intntnl airport.
LikeLike
He doesn’t know what to do with them, he didn’t really think this through, did he? I think they should put Murtha in there with the detainees.
LikeLike