Skip to content

Court rules Arizona’s proof of citizenship requirement for voter registration violates federal law

October 26, 2010

  Earlier today the  Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Arizona’s law which required people to show proof of citizenship when they registered to vote violates the federal law known as the National Voter Registration Act. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the Arizona law–which was passed by the voters in 2004 and is not part of the controversial immigration law that is currently being challenged by the Obama regime–provided an “additional hurdle” to people who wish to vote and is in direct conflict with the federal law which looks to reduce  “state-imposed obstacles” to people who are looking to register to vote.

  At the same time the court did rule that the Arizona law which requires people to show a valid ID card when they go to the polls to cast their vote was not in violation of the 14th amendment, so that is a partial victory but it does not lessen the effects of this disastrous ruling. By the time illegal aliens show up at the polls with their ill-gotten identification cards the horse will have been let out of the barn because they will have already registered to vote. At this point people who should have no right to vote will not be stopped from voting, so there is little solace in the fact that people will still be required to show ID cards.

  The court has ruled that asking a person to show proof that they are in this country legally before they are allowed to vote is a burden that is unfair to the people who broke the law to get into this country in the first place. What the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals feels is a burden, most Americans feel is common sense. If a person comes to this country illegally they should not have the right to affect our elections, it is as simple as that, but according to this decision Arizona does not have the right to ensure that only people who are eligible to vote are allowed to register to vote.

  When an American citizen registers to vote do they not have to show proof that they are of legal voting age? Yet illegal aliens are not to be bound to rules which prove that they meet voting requirements?

  The only upside to this decision is the fact that it has come too late to change the upcoming mid-term elections as the deadline for Arizona residents to register to vote has already passed for the mid-term election. But this is an issue that must be monitored closely. I am sure there will be an appeal of this decision in the near future and we can only hope that this ruling is overturned before the 2012 presidential election.

 Our country is slowly slipping away, and granting the right to our most sacred constitutional procedure to people who are not protected under the constitution amounts to nothing more than a watering down of the core principle that our representative constitutional republic is founded on, and we must stop this downward spiral before it is too late!

13 Comments leave one →
  1. LD Jackson's avatar
    LD Jackson permalink
    October 26, 2010 9:32 pm

    Great article about a very sore subject, Steve. I wrote about something similar to this today and it is very frustrating to see our sacred rights being handed over to people who have not met the requirements of citizenship. If they can’t be bothered to do that, then they shouldn’t be allowed to participate in our elections.

    Like

    • Steve Dennis's avatar
      October 27, 2010 7:16 pm

      Thanks Larry! I have no problem with people who go through the proper process to become citizens getting the right to vote once they are citizens, but to blindly give people who came here illegally and who do not bother to go through the citizenship process the right to vote is an insult to our sensibilities.

      Like

  2. Dominique's avatar
    October 26, 2010 10:02 pm

    “is a burden that is unfair to the people who broke the law to get into this country in the first place.”

    What does this court NOT get! These are ILLEGALS! They should not have ANY say. It is an unfair burden? Are you kidding me! Oh my gosh!

    Did somebody cast a spell of delusion, stupidity and outright idiocy over our courts and politicians? This is madness….

    I’d like to see this court go down to Mexico and demand their rights to vote in their elections! Someone, I don’t think that will happen!

    This just makes me ill…What is happening to my country!

    Errrrr….

    Like

    • Dominique's avatar
      October 26, 2010 10:11 pm

      Sorry – I meant to say here legally but not citizens. My bad.

      Like

    • Steve Dennis's avatar
      October 27, 2010 6:15 am

      It truly is infuriating what is going on in this country! We need to take back the Congress and begin the process of taking our country back!

      Like

  3. LD Jackson's avatar
    LD Jackson permalink
    October 26, 2010 10:22 pm

    There are so many things wrong with this picture, I hardly know where to start or what to say. This path we are on is a very dangerous and slippery path and the place it seems to lead is not pleasant.

    Like

  4. Professor Horsenutz's avatar
    Professor Horsenutz permalink
    October 27, 2010 6:42 am

    Given all the facts presented regarding our porus border with Meixco, it is obvious that any American citizen who opposes SB 1070 suffers from a depressed IQ!

    Like

  5. leisha's avatar
    leisha permalink
    October 27, 2010 8:45 am

    As long as voter registration can be completed by mail or on the computer now, there is no one stopping these folks. All they have to do is SWEAR they are a US citizen to register. There is no check or balance. Do you think there is someone sitting at a computer checking citizenship status of an applicant? NONONONONO.

    Twenty years ago, this wasn’t a problem. Now it is a huge problem. The government just relied on honesty, big mistake now. These laws and rules must be updated to suit the current and likely future problems with illegal immigration.

    The court was right to strike it down, but the 14th amendment says you must be a legal citizen to vote. Now the Federal Government must protect its citizenry, laws and the Constitution. We must add an amendment to the 14th to bring a birth certificate upon application. Yes this is a step backward for convenience but honestly who are we inconveniencing? So what! The fact that illegals will now just register in droves proves the point that this is STUPID AND OUR FEDERAL GOVERNTMENT IS NO LONGER FOR THE PEOPLE IT GOVERNS.

    Obama is the worst president ever.

    Like

    • Steve Dennis's avatar
      October 27, 2010 7:19 pm

      I just went back and checked the 14th amendment because I did not recall it saying that a person needed to be a citizen in order to vote, but you are exactly right! That provision is in there and any attempt to give illegals the right to vote is unconstitutional under the 14th amendment!

      Like

  6. rjjrdq's avatar
    October 27, 2010 5:17 pm

    these folks still have to show ID at the polls, but if they vote absentee, they never have to show up to vote. Basically, anyone on earth can cast an absentee vote in the United States.

    Couple that with the fact that many of our troops overseas may be denied the right to vote. This is insane.

    Like

    • Steve Dennis's avatar
      October 27, 2010 7:20 pm

      We are living in a backwards country when veterans are denied the right to vote but illegals will be voting! This is infuriating to think about!

      Like

    • thegeorgiayankee's avatar
      March 20, 2014 10:05 pm

      I read recently that 76 absentee ballots were thrown out because that jurisdiction had changed its rules to require voters to attach a copy of their photo ID to the absentee ballot. The voters didn’t read the rules and so their votes weren’t counted.

      But you’re right, rjj – absentee ballots are easily gamed, but state legislators have rarely taken any steps to tighten the rules to make it harder to monkey with them.

      By the way, did you know that the majority of absentee ballots are cast for Republican candidates? I wonder if there’s any causative relationship between that fact the the legislatures’ reluctance to make them tamperproof . . .

      Take good care, and may God bless us all!

      TGY

      Like

  7. Sirrahc's avatar
    November 28, 2010 11:01 pm

    I realize I’m a bit late in commenting on this, but I agree wholeheartedly. It’s a disturbing trend. Unfortunately, the real issues often get muddied by spurious claims of racism & discrimination, civil rights affronts, etc.

    Like

Leave a reply to Professor Horsenutz Cancel reply