Skip to content

Moderate Senate Democrats look at the possibility of repealing healthcare mandates

February 8, 2011

  Obamacare is under attack by conservatives, the courts, and a majority of the states and it now appears as if the opposition might be gaining an improbable, and valuable, ally in the fight–moderate Democrats. There is now talk among a handful of moderate Democrats about the possibility of repealing the healthcare mandates included in the healthcare reform law.

  According to this article Joe Manchin, Ben Nelson, Claire McCaskill, and Jon Tester–all of whom are up for re-election in 2012–are now exploring the idea of repealing the mandates, claiming that even though the voted for the bill they do not feel as if the mandates were the right avenue to pursue in the first place. While claiming that they are not looking at this through a political prism and are simply doing what they feel is right, I have to believe that this is politically motivated for they had the chance to stop the mandates BEFORE Obamacare became law, yet the voted for it knowing that the mandates were in the bill nonetheless. Now that the bill is seen as widely unpopular they are conveniently changing their position on this bill just before the 2012 election cycle kicks off.

  Regardless of their motivation for this conversion this is a welcome change indeed and it will be interesting to watch to see how many other vulnerable Democrats suddenly realize that the healthcare mandates were a bad idea (and unconstitutional) as the election draws closer. If the Senate continues to draw supporters to the healthcare mandates repeal movement it will prove to be a huge blow to Barack Obama even if the law survives this insurgency among the party.

     If this idea picks up steam in the Senate and enough Democrats do turn on the president and vote to repeal the healthcare mandates the healthcare reform bill will be dead because–as the judge in Florida declared–the healthcare mandates are inseparable from the overall bill. If the healthcare mandates fall by the wayside, so does the healthcare reform law.

  Moderate, vulnerable Democrats are talking a good game right now but will they have the courage to follow up on their words? If they do Barack Obama could be facing a challenge within his own party that he did not see coming. While the talking points in the mainstream media continue to be about the notion that the Tea Party is splitting the Republican party and may actually harm their re-election prospects in 2012, there is an insurrection growing within the Democrat party that the mainstream media is trying to ignore at all costs and if this story is any indication, the Democrat party may be splintering and the implosion could come in November of 2012.

  The American people must not be fooled by this change of heart in these Democrats and they must vote out any and all Democrats who voted for this bill–even those that may vote to repeal the healthcare mandates because the fact remains that these Democrats did not listen to the will of the people in the first place and voted with the leadership and the president when they felt as if it was politically expedient to do so, and they simply cannot be trusted. While we should welcome them belatedly into the fold we must not forget that we wouldn’t be in this precarious position if they had not voted for a bill in the first place which they now claim is flawed.

12 Comments leave one →
  1. rjjrdq's avatar
    February 9, 2011 4:40 am

    I guess you could describe those Dems as, “for it before they were against it.” Maybe they finally got around to reading it and realized what they actually voted for.

    Like

  2. LD Jackson's avatar
    LD Jackson permalink
    February 9, 2011 10:39 am

    I suspect the only reason the Democrats you mentioned are having second thoughts about the health care law is how they are perceiving their reelection chances. That’s a far cry from having a real epiphany and realizing the mistake they made by voting for the bill.

    Like

    • Steve Dennis's avatar
      February 9, 2011 8:19 pm

      I am glad you are feeling better Larry and I agree with you, the only reason that these Democrats are now looking at repealing the mandate is because they are trying to protect themselves for the 2012 election, but if that is what it takes for the mandates to be repealed I will accept that. Although I still think they should be voted out for voting for this bill in the first place.

      Like

  3. Bunkerville's avatar
    February 9, 2011 12:35 pm

    Bill Bennet this morning had a good back and forth about it. The guest was arguing that the Republicans should never go along with any changes. The Dems will say they are making changes, and it helps those Dems in trouble get re-elected. Thus if the GOP does not get to 60 they may not be able to overturn the whole thing. On the other side, if they don’t go along, it makes the Republicans look bad and are the party of no. (A very poor description of the debate on my part)> The guest felt that it was best to keep all of the nasty stuff in there so the issue will remain an ugly bill. He was upset that the Republicans went along with the amendment that just past . Interesting debate.

    Like

    • Steve Dennis's avatar
      February 9, 2011 8:21 pm

      It sounds as if it was interesting but I do not think that the Republicans should allow the bill to stand as is just because they can use it against the Democrats in two years; this bill must be repealed as soon as possible and I do not care who gets the credit for it.

      Like

  4. Mike's avatar
    Mike permalink
    February 9, 2011 12:36 pm

    Doesn’t it bother you that taxpayers and the insured are subsidizing the health care of the uninsured? How do we address that problem?

    Like

    • Steve Dennis's avatar
      February 9, 2011 8:25 pm

      The first question I would ask is this; how many of the people who are using the emergency room as a doctor visit are illegal aliens who shouldn’t be here in the first place? I don’t know the answer to that question but I would guess that it is probably close to a majority, so I would start by cracking down on illegal immigration. That would be a great place to start. And hospitals are not going to refuse anybody care–and they shouldn’t–but those people should be billed for the services they use. The hospitals are more than willing to work with people who have no insurance to work out a payment plan and that is what should be done by those who use the services. This will not solve the whole problem, but it seems like a good place to start.

      Like

  5. Reaganite Republican's avatar
    February 9, 2011 1:33 pm

    Politics is starting to get fun again, Steve

    Have to say pretty happy with the GOP leadership so far… pretty
    aggressive, I love it

    Like

    • Steve Dennis's avatar
      February 9, 2011 8:25 pm

      It sure is good to see the Republicans step up and make good on their promises to the American people.

      Like

  6. John Carey's avatar
    February 9, 2011 11:24 pm

    Ahhhh the DC two step. Vote however they want regardless of what their constituents want, then when they are up for reelection run to the center. The people tend to fall for this every single time. Ask John McCain. He just two stepped his way back to DC for another 6 years.

    Like

    • Steve Dennis's avatar
      February 10, 2011 7:21 am

      A good point John. Hopefully we can use this two step to our advantage and repeal the mandate, then we can still boot them out to make sure they can’t do this to us again. Hopefully their constituents won’t be fooled by their recent “conversion.”

      Like

Leave a reply to Bunkerville Cancel reply